[ ÕŰ®¾ü ]¡ª¡ª(2002-11-25) / ÒÑÔÄ72350´Î
¢à ÍõÀûÃ÷£¬¡¶³Í·£ÐÔÅâ³¥Ñо¿¡·£¬ÔÔØ¡¶ÖйúÉç»á¿ÆÑ§¡·2000ÄêµÚ4ÆÚ
¢Ù Íõ³ÉÖø£¬¡¶ÇÖȨËðº¦Åâ³¥µÄ¾¼Ã·ÖÎö¡·£¬±±¾©£¬ÖйúÈËÃñ´óѧ³ö°æÉ磬2002Äê°æ£¬p.192
¢Ú Íõ³ÉÖø£¬¡¶ÇÖȨËðº¦Åâ³¥µÄ¾¼Ã·ÖÎö¡·£¬±±¾©£¬ÖйúÈËÃñ´óѧ³ö°æÉ磬2002Äê°æ£¬p.193
¢Ù ±ÊÕß×¢£º±¾ÎĵĹ۵ãÓë´ËÓгöÈë¡£
¢Ú ¹ØÓÚÊýѧÉϵÄÍÆµ¼£¬¼ûSee Cooter, Robert D, Economic Analysis of Punitive Damages, Mathematical Appendix, pp.99-100£¬¾ùתÒý×ÔÍõ³ÉÖø£¬¡¶ÇÖȨËðº¦Åâ³¥µÄ¾¼Ã·ÖÎö¡·£¬±±¾©£¬ÖйúÈËÃñ´óѧ³ö°æÉ磬2002Äê°æ£¬p.194-195
¢Û κÕñ壬¡¶ÂÛÃñ·¨µäÖеÄÃñÊÂÔðÈÎÌåϵ¡ª¡ªÎÒ¹úÃñ·¨µäÓ¦½¨Á¢ÐµÄÃñÊÂÔðÈÎÌåϵ¡·£¬ÔÔØÓÚ¡¶Öйú·¨Ñ§¡·2001ÄêµÚ3ÆÚ
¢Ü ±¾ÎÄËùÌÖÂ۵ķ¶Î§£¬¼´ÕÅб¦½ÌÊÚËù½²µÄÏÁÒå¸ÅÄ¼û±¾ÎĵÚÒ»²¿·Ö¡£
¢Ý ²Î¼û¿ËÀ×˹µÙ°²¡¤·ë¡¤°Í¶û£º¡¶Å·ÖޱȽÏÇÖȨÐÐΪ·¨¡·£¬ÕÅб¦Ò룬·¨Âɳö°æÉç2001Äê°æ£¬µÚ743Ò³ÒÔÏ¡£
¢Ù ²Î¼ûYzqierdo Tolsada, Responsabilida civil, pp.40-41.
¢Ú ÕÅб¦£¬¡¶ÖйúÃñ·¨µä¡¤ÇÖȨÐÐΪ·¨±à²Ý°¸½¨Òé¸åÀíÓɸÅ˵¡·
¢Ù ¡¶±£»¤Ïû·ÑÕßÈ¨Òæ¡¯£¹£¹°¸Àý¡·Ñ¡±à ¡£
¢Ú ÐìÑ¸Öø£¬¡¶ÎªÇå°×¶øÕ½££Ï£Íû¹¤³Ì¿çÊÀ¼Í´óËÏÕ½¼Íʵ¡·£¬ÖйúÇàÄê³ö°æÉç2000Äê7Ô³ö°æ£¬ÕªÒª¿¯ÔØ¡¶Öйú·¨ÂÉ¡·£¨Ïã¸Û³ö°æ£©2000ÄêµÚ3ÆÚ ¡¶Ò¼ÖÜ¿¯¡··Ì°ùÏ£Íû¹¤³Ì°¸·Ã̸¼£¨Ï£©¡£
¢Û U. S. Dept. of Justice, Civil¡¡Jury¡¡cases¡¡andVerdicts in Large Counties (1995).
¢Ü ÍõÀûÃ÷£¬¡¶³Í·£ÐÔÅâ³¥Ñо¿¡·£¬ÔÔØ¡¶ÖйúÉç»á¿ÆÑ§¡·2000ÄêµÚ4ÆÚ¡£
¢Ý ´Þ½¨Ô¶Ö÷±à¡¶ÐºÏͬ·¨ÔÀíÓë°¸ÀýÆÀÎö¡·£¨ÉÏ£©£¬¼ªÁÖ´óѧ³ö°æÉç1999Äê°æ£¬ µÚ484Ò³¡£
¢Þ ÍõÀûÃ÷£¬¡¶³Í·£ÐÔÅâ³¥Ñо¿¡·£¬ÔÔØ¡¶ÖйúÉç»á¿ÆÑ§¡·2000ÄêµÚ4ÆÚ¡£
¢ß ³Â¹âÖÐÖ÷±à£¬Íô½¨³É׫¸å£¬¡¶ÐÌÊÂËßËÏ·¨¡·£¬±±¾©£¬¸ßµÈ½ÌÓý³ö°æÉçºÍ±±¾©´óѧ³ö°æÉ磬2002Äê°æ£¬p.211
¢à ×î¸ßÈËÃñ·¨Ôº¹ØÓÚÊÊÓá¶ÖлªÈËÃñ¹²ºÍ¹úÃñÊÂËßËÏ·¨¡·Èô¸ÉÎÊÌâµÄÒâ¼ûµÚ294¡¢295Ìõ¡£
¢á ±ÊÕß×¢£º²»ÅųýÔÚÇé½ÚÑÏÖØµÄʱºòÒÔ·¸×ïÂÛ¡£
¢â ½Î°Ö÷±à£¬³Â¹ðÃ÷׫¸å£¬¡¶ÃñÊÂËßËÏ·¨¡·£¬±±¾©£¬¸ßµÈ½ÌÓý³ö°æÉçºÍ±±¾©´óѧ³ö°æÉ磬2000Äê°æ p.386
11 Ronald A. Brand, Punitive Damages and the Recognition of Judgnents, 43, Netherland International Law Review, p.145(1996).
12 ÓÐѧÕßÈÏΪ£¬³Í·£ÐÔÅâ³¥ÆðÔ´ÓÚ¡¶ººÚÓÀ±È·¨µä¡·£¬Ëü¹æ¶¨Èç¹ûÒ»¸öÈË´ÓËÂԺ͵ÁËÒ»Ö»¶¯ÎËû¾Í±ØÐëÅâ³¥ËÂÔº30±¶µÄ¶¯Îï¡£²Î¼û¹ùÓñ¾ü£º¡¶¹ú¼ÊÉÌÊÂÖÙ²ÃÖеijͷ£ÐÔÅâ³¥²Ã¾ö¡·£¬ÔØ¡¶·¨Ñ§ÆÀÂÛ¡·£¬2000£¨1£©£¬×ªÒý×ÔÍõ³É¡¶ÇÖȨËðº¦Åâ³¥µÄ¾¼Ã·ÖÎö¡·¡£
×ܹ²5Ò³¡¡¡¡[1] [2] [3] [4] 5
ÉÏÒ»Ò³¡¡¡¡