[ ʯ±ØÊ¤ ]¡ª¡ª(2013-3-6) / ÒÑÔÄ20893´Î
[47]82 USPQ2d at 1395.
[48]82 USP02d at 1395.
[49]82 USPQ2d at 1395.
[50]82 USPQ2d at 1395.
[51]Graham, 383 U. S£¬at 36.
[52]DyStar Textilfarben GmbH£¦Co. Deutschland KG v. C. H. Patrick Co.£¬464 F. 3d 1356, 1367 £¨2006£©.
[53]Agrizap v. Woodstream Corp.£¬No. 07-1415 £¨Fed. Cir. March 28 , 2008£©.
[54]Ortho-McNeil Pharmaceutical v. Mylan Labs, No. 07-1223 £¨Fed. Cir. March 31£¬2008£©.
[55][µÂ]¸ñÂÞ˹·Æ¶ûµÂ£º¡¶±È½Ï·¨µÄÁ¦Á¿ÓëÈõµã¡·£¬ËïÊÀÑå/Ò¦½¨×ÚÒ룬Ç廪´óѧ³ö°æ2002Äê°æ¡£
[56]ͬע19ÒýÎÄ£¬µÚ443Ò³¡£
[57]¡¶Å·ÖÞרÀû¾ÖרÀûÉó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚÈý²¿·ÖµÚËÄÕµÚ9.4½Ú¡£
[58]¡¶Å·ÖÞרÀû¾ÖרÀûÉó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚÈý²¿·ÖµÚËÄÕµÚ11.4½Ú¡£
[59]ÈðÆæ£º¡°µÚ103ÌõΪʲôÒÔ¼°ÈçºÎÖÆ¶¨¡±£¬ÔØÍþɪ˹ÅÓÖ÷±à£º¡¶·ÇÏÔ¶øÒ×¼ûÐÔ¡ª×¨ÀûÐÔµÄ×îÖÕÌõ¼þ¡·,BNA¹«Ë¾1980Äê°æ£¬µÚ209Ò³[Giles S. Rich, Why and How Section 103 Came to Be, in John F. Witherspoon ed.£¬Non obviousness¡ªThe Ultimate Condition of Patentability, Virginia.. Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. 1980£¬p. 209£®]¡£
[60]In re Wiseman, 596 F. 2d 1019, 201 USPQ 658£¨C. C. P. A. 1979£©£®
[61]¡¶ÃÀ¹úרÀûÉó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚ2145½Ú[Manual of Patent Examining Procedure £¨MPEP£©£¬¡ì 2145. II, Eighth Edition, Au-gust 2001 , Latest Revision July 2010. ]¡£
[62]¡¶ÈÕ±¾×¨ÀûÉó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚ¶þ²¿·ÖµÚ¶þÕµÚ2.5½Ú°¸Àý1¡£
[63]2006Äê¡¶Éó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚ¶þ²¿·ÖµÚËÄÕµÚ3.2.1.1½Ú¡£
[64][ÃÀ]ÈüµÂÂü£º¡°ÆÀ°¢À¼•ÎÖɵġ¶·¨ÂÉÒÆÖ²¡·£º±È½Ï·¨µÄ·½·¨¡±£¬Íõ³¿¹âÒë£¬ÔØ¡¶ÖÐÍⷨѧ¡·1989ÄêµÚ5ÆÚ£¬µÚ58Ò³¡£
[65]Graham v. John Deere Co.£¬383 U.S. 1£¬17-18£¨1966£©£®
[66]Clark v. Wright Aeronautical Corp. , 162 F. 2d 960 £¨2d Cir. 1947£©.
[67][ÃÀ]¿Â»ô´ï˹£º¡°×¨Àû·¨Ö®¸¸¡±£¬ÔØ¡¶·¨ÖÆÊ±±¨¡·1995Äê7ÔÂ10ÈÕµÚ1°æ£¨Nadine Cohodas, The Founding Father of Patent Law. Legal Times£¬July 10 , 1995, p. 1£©¡£
[68]ͬע59ÒýÎÄ£¬µÚ208Ò³¡£
[69]Wire Wheel Corp. of America v. C. T. Silver, Inc.£¬266 F. 221£¬227 £¨S. D. N. Y. 1919 £©£¬affd, 266 F. 229 £¨2dCir. 1920£©.
[70]Van H eusen Products v. Earl£¦Wilson, 300 F. 922, 929 £¨S. D. N. Y. 1924£©.
[71]Diamond Rubber Co. v. Consolidated Rubber Tire Co.£¬220 U. S. 428, 430 £¨1911£©£®
[72]KSR, 82 USPQ2d 1385£¬at1397.
[73]¡¶ÃÀ¹úרÀûÉó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚ2144½Ú[Manual of Patent Examining Procedure £¨MPEP£© , ¡ì 2144, Eighth Edition, August 2001 , Latest Revision July 2010.]¡£
[74]Reiner v. I. Leon Co. ,285 F. 2d 501£¬503-04 £¨2d Cir. 1960£©£®
[75]¡¶ÃÀ¹úרÀûÉó²éÖ¸ÄÏ¡·µÚ2141½Ú[Manual of Patent Examining Procedure £¨MPEP£©£¬¡ì 2144. III, Eighth Edition, Au-gust 2001 , Latest Revision July 2010.]¡£
[76]Diamond Rubber Co. v. Consolidated Rubber Tire Co.£¬220 U.S. 428, 435 £¨1911£©£®
[77]ÃÀ¹úÁª°îóÒ×ίԱ»á£º¡¶´Ù½ø´´Ð£º×¨Àû·¨ÓëÕþ²ßµÄÊÊ¶ÈÆ½ºâ¡·£¬µÚ8Ò³[Federal Trade Commission, To Promote Innovation : The Proper Balance of Competition and Patent Law and Policy £¨2003 £©£¬p. 8.]¡£
³ö´¦:¡¶±È½Ï·¨Ñо¿¡·2012ÄêµÚ5ÆÚ
£¨×÷Õßµ¥Î»£º»ª¶«Õþ·¨´óѧ£©
×ܹ²3Ò³¡¡¡¡[1] [2] 3
ÉÏÒ»Ò³¡¡¡¡